PART 3 OF 7
Providence in Unrighteousness
In the unexpected events of the Old Testament, we find the story of Thamar, the daughter-in-law of Judah, the fourth-born son of Jacob. In the Gospel of Matthew, Thamar is the first woman mentioned as part of the Messianic genealogy. However, when the scroll of the Old Testament is rolled back, we may see that Thamar’s situation, to be given into marriage, conceive children and have a family, is not a rosy one. What is more, we learn from Genesis 38 about ancient marriage customs. Which, at the least, Western society would not approve of, would dispute and stand against.
The Bible’s narrative of this event poses a challenge and is rather difficult to see through: Thamar. The predominant theme is human failure and men who were ungodly. Judah, Er and Onan are all examples from whom we ought to learn how not to act and behave when it comes to marriage, family life and the responsibility of a patriarch. Nonetheless, I propose that we look beyond human failure and shortfalls. Ultimately, to see that God was sovereign and working with the fallen human will and the outcomes of it. Thamar will be remembered throughout history and the Bible. God’s providence steered an ugly situation turning into a blessing.1
Levirate Marriage
The Genesis narrative begins with Judah taking a Canaanite as a wife who bore three sons: Er, Onan and Shelah. When the boys were old enough, from Judah’s perspective, to be given into marriage, Judah took a wife for his firstborn, Er, named Thamar. Er was a wicked man in the eyes of the Lord. We have to understand here that even though the Bible does not say what evil Er did, it was indeed grave for God to take the ultimate measure against him and leave behind no children.
In those times, there was a marriage custom that the widow of the older brother was to be given in marriage to the next younger brother. This custom had Ancient Near East roots, and it is called Levirate2, which Moses will legalise3 and continue at least until Jesus’ time4. Judah, as head of his house, therefore instructs his second son to take Thamar as wife and by going in unto her to raise seed for his brother Er. However, Onan disobeys the Levirate marriage custom and his father’s instruction. Acknowledging that the firstborn will not be recognised as Onan’s, but his brother Er’s. Onan refused to have children and deliberately prevented offspring from being raised for his brother. God was so displeased with Onan. The judgment against him was the same as Er’s, and he died without leaving behind offspring.
These two events must have drawn Judah’s attention. Having the eldest two sons die and perhaps knowing that it was God’s judgment, he sends Thamar back to her father to live as a widow, promising her that when Shelah, the third son, is ready, she will be given to him as a wife. However, time passes, and the promise is delayed. The wise Solomon may help us understand Thamar’s heart. That when hope is deferred, the heart is sickened.5 What is more, Thamar’s experience with Er’s wickedness and Onan’s abuse of Levirate custom must have deeply harmed her.
Righteous Judgment
Thamar, hearing that her father-in-law will pass by, having been bound by the Levirate custom and denied the marriage promised to her, takes an extraordinary course of action. She removes herself from the obligation of widowhood and takes an extreme attitude and appearance. We would be entering the speculation realm if we started to discuss what Thamar’s intentions were. To dress as a harlot and sit in the way of Judah’s, and perhaps Shelah’s, passing. However, the narrative continues and describes that Judah, thinking she was a harlot, joins in with her, and the outcome reveals Judah’s failure, himself recognising it. A pledge was asked by Thamar as a guarantee of payment before the hideous act happened. Judah agreed and gave her his personal belongings: the signet, bracelets, and staff, which would easily identify the owner.
After days and months, Judah is informed that his daughter-in-law was pregnant. Such could have only happened by an immoral act, as she had no husband, but was waiting on one to be given to. Therefore, the obvious conclusion was that Thamar was guilty of prostitution.
The binding of widowhood and the Levirate gave Judah the authority to judge and sentence his daughter-in-law, which he hastily decided: to be burnt to death. We may judge that Judah was correct in his discernment, as the act of prostitution and the breaking of widowhood and the Levirate were grievous deeds Thamar was guilty of. Taking, therefore, the righteous position to judge Thamar and cause her to die. However, the tables will be turned against him, and then he will eventually be judging righteously no one else but himself.
Against the Pledge
On a personal note, I do not think Thamar was entirely without blame in this situation. This is one of the many examples of people taking matters into their own hands. It appears Thamar knew the man’s weakness, and even though the text does not explicitly state her intentions, we can see that Thamar’s motivation was to go out and be in the way of Judah’s passing through. She saw, therefore knew that Shelah had grown and was ready for marriage6. However, she had not been given to him as a wife, as the Levirate custom required and Judah promised. She had faithfully waited so far. However, I think that Thamar acted from her own weaknesses too. So when two fallen individuals meet who are led by their weaknesses, trusting in their own wisdom, it will rather turn against them, revealing human moral corruption. The Levirate marriage custom had a protective character towards women and the family she was marrying into. Thamar was promised to be given as a wife to Shelah, and the Levirate was the guarantee that, though a widow, she was not forever.
Thamar’s response to Judah’s judgment call was to send back the pledge: the signet, bracelets, and staff. Asking therefore him to discern that whoever owns them is the father of the child in her womb. The judgment request and the sentence have now turned against him. Discernment served Judah well, admitting and acknowledging that he had done wrong. Determining that Thamar acted more righteously than he did.
Preserving the Blood Line
The story opens and closes abruptly. The protective character of the Levirate custom was known by Thamar, Judah and Shelah, and approved by God. However, what I want us all to take away is that men have failed here both the Levirate and God’s law. Thamar was to be protected; Judah failed God and the Levirate custom. He recognised his shortfall, and by the following statement, “And he knew her again no more.”7 We get to understand that he changed his perspective and character. “She hath been more righteous than I; because that I gave her not to Shelah my son.”8 And that was in Judah’s decision. Therefore, whatever his motivations were to delay or perhaps never give Thamar as a wife to Shelah, turned against him. Judah claims the authority to judge righteousness, but Thamar becomes the one through whom his unrighteousness is exposed.
Nonetheless, God was smoothly and quietly directing the outcome. What I find marvellous about this story is that God worked with and within the human conventions of marriage. This is an example where we see God not only respecting the human construct of marriage. But He is working with human free will, even when it fails to follow its own laws and customs. Human will determined the means, but God drew the outcome9. The narrative continues, describing that Thamar gave birth to twins and the sons will be recognised as Judah’s. Perez would then become the forefather of the Royal Blood Line: Davidic and Messianic. But until then, more is yet to come. From this point, we are not far away from Jacob’s sons becoming tribes and from there to becoming a nation. Jesus’ earthly genealogy is rooted in Perez, the son of Thamar. Matthew, in his genealogy, moved by the holy ghost, chooses to explicitly name Perez as the son of Judah, begat of Thamar.10 Pointing to failure and righteousness worked out by God’s providence within such an unexpected situation. In His sovereignty, God is the only one able, from a fallen and sinful situation, to raise a righteous outcome echoing in eternity. That is what defines God’s Sovereignty and Redemptive character.
The woman’s role remains vital, and the conceived children are valuable human beings and contribute to God’s Redemptive plan. Such situations may seem hideous today, and those who might get punished for it would likely be the individuals from Thamar’s womb. Regardless of how troubling the circumstances of Perez and Zerah’s conception may be, their worth is not determined by them. I think this historical event speaks loudly and clearly: every human being is valuable beyond measure, playing a beautifully unique role in humanity’s history. Hence, the womb ought to remain the safest place for the human being: from conception up to birth and beyond it.
Patriarchy failed its own commitments and responsibilities. Nonetheless, such situations do show that the roles of men and women are complementary and not competing. Advocates for equality may point out that one was the victim and the other was the abuser. However, patriarchy these days is wrongly understood because it has been misdefined. In the Bible, hence in Christianity, patriarchy is not defined as the man or the father figure, achieving his goals through abuse and oppression. It is rather the opposite. Biblical patriarchy describes a family structure in which the father or male head bears authority and responsibility for the household, with that authority accountable to God’s standards of righteousness, justice and care. So, when the patriarch fails, he first misrepresents God, and then betrays those in his care to protect and provide. Judah’s failure does not invalidate his responsibilities, while Thamar’s vindication demonstrates that her moral standing was not dependent upon his authority. Hence, accountability must not fall upon those who were conceived, but upon those who failed to honour the Levirate covenant and uphold God’s righteousness.
The man and the woman have their own value, and what gives each a beautifully unique worth is the fulfilment of their roles. When those roles are neglected, their distinctive value diminishes; when interchanged, their distinctiveness is destroyed.
God had promised Abraham, Isaac and Jacob that a great nation would come out of them. That the Messiah would come out of their line. Judah was chosen by God as the forefather. The plan continues, and the goal, as we will see by the end of this Redemptive story, Feminism and Femininity, at some specific and unexpected turns in human history, God remains in control. Directing the paths and, out of the ashes, bringing Christ, the Saviour, as promised to the Serpent, Eve and Adam.
Bible References
NEXT IN THE SERIES · Feminism and Femininity – From Promise to Fulfilment
PART 4 OF 7 · Rahab, Faithful Beyond the Walls – Continuing our exploration of the woman’s significance in God’s unfolding redemptive purposes.
- Read PART 1 – Feminism and Femininity – The Grace of Judgement
- Read PART 2 – Feminism and Femininity – Eve, the Mother of All Living
Discover more from AvA blog
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.




